http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/01/business/01ECON.html

August 1, 2001

Consumers Splurge While Confidence Wanes
By MICHAEL BRICK

American consumers increased their spending in June, especially on expensive items like cars and refrigerators, but their confidence about the economy over the next few months has recently deteriorated, raising questions about whether such spending can continue at its current pace.

The latest data come from two economic reports issued yesterday, leaving economists divided as to whether consumers, who have helped keep the economy afloat through a sharp downturn in business investment, will continue to maintain their spending.

Some fear that the latest round of high-profile job cuts will undermine consumers' confidence, causing them to spend more cautiously. Other economists argue that declining energy prices, the coming tax rebates and the effect of lower interest rates are about to ease the overall downturn, negating the impact of recent job cuts.

"Consumer spending really has decelerated, yet it's still moving forward," said Joel Prakken, chairman of Macroeconomic Advisers, a consulting firm in St. Louis. "That's really heartening because employment has stalled."

The Conference Board's consumer confidence index, which is based on a monthly survey of Americans aimed at eliciting their views of their own finances and expectations for the overall economy, fell to 116.5 in July from 118.9 in June. The June figure had been revised higher, and economists were expecting a reading of about 118 for July. It was the first decline since April, but the index remains above its recent low of 109.2 in February, when it reached the lowest mark since 1996.

Consumer spending, meanwhile, rose 0.4 percent in June, the Commerce Department reported, surpassing the consensus of economists' expectations of 0.3 percent, which would have matched the increase in May. The increase included a 1.5 percent rise in spending on durable goods, expensive things like household appliances that can require financing and, sometimes, arguments.

Adjusted for price changes, Americans spent 1.6 percent more on durable goods in June than they did in May, and 7 percent more than in June 2000. Overall spending rose an inflation-adjusted 0.2 percent in June from the month before and 3.1 percent over a year earlier. 

The sharp jump in spending on durable goods could be caused by car dealers and department stores offering steep promotional discounts, said John Youngdahl, a senior economist at Goldman, Sachs & Company. "It raises a question of whether, in doing so, they are borrowing against their future sales," he said.

Personal income rose 0.3 percent, also exceeding by one-tenth of one percentage point the prior month's increase and the expectations of economists.

A separate report from the National Association of Purchasing Management in Chicago showed a sharp decline in manufacturing in the Midwest. The trade group said its monthly index fell to 38 in July, the lowest reading since March, from 44.4 in June.

The Labor Department plans to report on the unemployment rate for July on Friday, and economists expect the rate will rise to 4.7 percent from 4.5 percent in June. It has climbed from 4 percent at the end of last year.

The more the July unemployment report shows that "the breadth of weakness in the employment market has spread outside the manufacturing sector," Mr. Youngdahl said, "the greater the danger that consumers lose confidence and lose their propensity to spend."

Of all the new data, the consumer confidence report offered the most up-to-date assessment, and it showed that Americans' perceptions of the current economic situation were declining far faster than their hopes for the next six months or so. The index measuring how consumers feel about their present situation fell 3 percent, to 152, from 156.8, while the index of future expectations fell 0.6 percent, to 92.9, from 93.5.

"I'm not at all surprised that people are miserable as sin right now; you've got a little industry of doom," said Ian Shepherdson, the chief domestic economist at High Frequency Economics in Valhalla, N.Y. "Companies want low interest rates, and it's in their best interest to talk down expectations."

But, he added, "big, headline-grabbing layoffs are not a leading indicator of the economy."


Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company | Privacy Information